Thursday, August 23, 2012

Preaching to the unconverted

Via Daring Fireball I came across this scathing review of Windows 8. I've come across two very distinct takes on the Windows 8 experience. More positive reviews come from those who've tried it out on tablets and are excited about the experience. The negative takes tend to come from those who are more or less happy with the traditional Windows experience and, by and large, hate Microsoft's combination of two distinct interfaces. This is the risk that MS is running: by "refusing to compromise" and combining a tablet interface with a traditional Windows desktop, they're providing a one-size-fits-all experience that, in the end, doesn't fit all.

If you want customers to learn a new interface, you need to make the value proposition very clear. Apple had a relatively easy scenario, because the iPhone/iPad experience was marketed only to people who wanted a phone or a tablet and so could easily see the benefit of a touch-optimized experience. Microsoft, on the other hand, is confronting a very large body of customers who already use Windows, are already comfortable with a certain way of doing things, and may have no intention of buying a tablet in the near future. For them, all they want is to use the interface conventions that they've already learned, and the new design gets in their way without offering anything very compelling in return.

Touch interfaces and mouse/keyboard interfaces are very different, both functionally and conceptually. At work I use an iPad and a Dell laptop, and with the magic of screen-sharing software I'm able to load my Windows desktop on my iPad screen. To some extent I can get it to work using multitouch and pinch-to-zoom, but it's an awkward experience and it's very much slower than using the tools that are specifically designed to work in that scenario. I do it when I need to -- when doing so solves a problem -- but otherwise I prefer to wait until I'm back at my desk.

Microsoft's design decision removes that choice. The touch-optimized interface presents itself wherever you are, even if you don't have a touch-sensitive screen or trackpad to work with. That's probably fine -- great, even -- if you're using a tablet device, and maybe Microsoft's true bet is that the desktop is going the way of the microcomputer and soon we'll be laughing about the days when we used two-button mice to select things on our screens. If they're wrong, though, and the traditional desktop interface has some life in it yet, then Windows 8 could be a latter-day Vista: a version of Windows that customers choose to skip, in the hope that the next version will be better conceived.

Tuesday, July 31, 2012

First principles

Wired.co.uk has a brief interview with Jonathan Ive, in which he reiterates a point first made by Steve Jobs:
"We are really pleased with our revenues but our goal isn't to make money. It sounds a little flippant, but it's the truth. Our goal and what makes us excited is to make great products. If we are successful people will like them and if we are operationally competent, we will make money."
I suspect that there will be two reactions to this statement. Those who are inclined to hate Apple will think, "What a bunch of self-serving bull$%&^." Those who are sympathetic to Apple will think, "Yes, exactly -- and that's what makes all the difference."

My own orientation is that Ive is on the level, and for one reason: it explains something that is otherwise inexplicable. The puzzle with Apple isn't how it managed to get so big -- other companies have been big before, and others will become big in the future. The puzzle with Apple is how it manages to overcome the famous innovator's dilemma. Companies are not supposed to be able to disrupt themselves, as Apple did by naming the iPhone the best music player it ever built at a time when the iPod was critical to its bottom line, and by releasing the iPad in the full knowledge that it would cannibalize sales of the highly profitable Apple laptops. The principles of sound business management are supposed to make it impossible to choose an uncertain market over a certain one. And yet Apple has done this repeatedly.

The key, I believe, is in Ive's statement. The innovator's dilemma describes a manager's inability to abandon a profitable position in order to develop a market that might become profitable later. A manager whose professional well-being depends first and foremost on profits will experience this problem. But take the same manager and focus him instead on making the best product, tell him not to worry about profits, and that changes everything. Then the company disrupts itself as a matter of course. With that one change in perspective, the innovator's dilemma becomes almost irrelevant.

If this orientation accurately describes what it's like to work at Apple, building that culture within the organization was Steve Jobs' greatest achievement, and the biggest test of his successors at Apple will be how long they can maintain that focus on product over profits. It's the key to everything.

Friday, July 27, 2012

Razor thin

There are some headlines this morning on Amazon's quarterly earnings, in which their razor-thin margins got even more so. MG Siegler opines thusly:
Yes, I realize Amazon is viewed as a growth business (forgoing short-term profits for long-term gains). But these numbers keep going the wrong way. At some point, they have to start going the right way, right?
I suspect that the answer to that question is "wrong" -- at least for the foreseeable future. Jeff Bezos plays one card consistently, and that's the "trade profits for market share" card. If you look at Amazon's historical earnings, they have a remarkable ability to stay just above (or below) the break-even line. Bezos is in it for the long term, and his long-term play is to keep prices as low as possible until his competitors either go out of business or leave the market in search of profits.

Lately I've heard Amazon compared to Apple, but that is a fundamental error. Amazon is not the new Apple, and has no intention of becoming so. Amazon is the new Dell.